Which is better than wines 8 or 10. The best version of Windows. Negative user reviews

One of the marketing promises Windows 10- even more fast work(the corresponding slogan sounds like "Designed for speed"). Compared to Win 8.1, the system should turn on faster, wake up from sleep mode, etc. But is it really so? Check it out!

Test device and raw data

For tests, a top-end multimedia laptop was taken - ASUS UX-501... Configuration: Intel Core i7 (overclocked to 3.6 GHz), 16 GB random access memory, a GeForce 960M GTX graphics card and a 128 GB SSD. This is one of the most interesting devices 2015 year.

A clean installation of both versions of Windows, software (drivers, test programs) was performed. The test was carried out in a room with a temperature of 23 degrees, the "Optimal" power consumption mode was selected, all tasks using the command Rundll32.exe, advapi32.dll, ProcessIdleTasks were installed, all the proposed Microsoft updates, all suggested Windows functions optimization. All tests were performed three times, the arithmetic mean was entered in the tables.

Testing

1. Boot time

The Windows® Performance Toolkit was used - a set of tools that manufacturers of Windows devices and programs use it when they want to test the runtime and speed of their products on average computers. The result of version 8.1 is on the left, tens - on the right, the unit of measurement is seconds:

The difference can not be called a big one, but it is clear that Microsoft still decided to spend time and do better, an already excellent indicator - Windows 10 is 0.7 seconds faster than its predecessor. On a top-end device like the UX-501, the owner of the device won't notice much difference, but on a regular laptop or PC, the difference can become much more noticeable.

Winner: Windows 10

2. Launch Internet Explorer

While working with a computer, we constantly open and close applications. The long loading time of an important program for the work is not only annoying (and nerves, as you know, are not iron), but also interferes with work or surfing the Internet.

Measurements are performed using the Windows Assessment Toolkit. The unit of measurement is milliseconds:

Again, not everyone will notice an improvement in the indicator from 0.9 seconds to 0.45 seconds - but such an indicator in any case warms the soul, Microsoft took care of the user here too.

Winner: Windows 10

3. Typing, web browsing and video chat

To carry out these tests, the benchmark tool PCMark 8 was taken. It simulates scenarios from real life: surfing the Internet, working in Office 2013, Adobe Creative Suite and other programs that are usually used at home and in the office for work. The exact time to complete the task is measured, down to milliseconds:

The differences are minimal - only 1%. True, it's all the same in favor of Windows 10.

Winner: Windows 10

4. Performance in Word, Powerpoint and Excel

PCMark measures the speed of work in basic office applications - for example, the processing time of a large spreadsheet in Excel:

But here the gain is much more obvious: it seems that office workers connected with calculations should really upgrade to the top ten.

Winner: Windows 10

5. Grand Theft Auto V

God bless him, with the office - let's play! The test passes Best game 2015 - GTA V, its own built-in benchmark is responsible for measuring FPS (frames per second).

The first "defeat" of the new OS from Microsoft. But it is worth remembering that the "ten" supports DirectX 12, which makes games up to 50% faster than before. The only thing is small - to finally wait for such games.

Winner: Windows 8.1

6. Adobe Creative Suite

Good performance is needed not only by gamers and nervous housewives, but also by IT professionals. A case in point is Adobe Creative Suite:

And again the victory - more than convincing, as much as 17% - for Windows 10. Microsoft has worked on the use of resources and drivers, so for every self-respecting IT specialist “ten” is not a luxury, but an urgent need.

Winner: Windows 10

7. Battery life (office)

Microsoft promises that Windows 10 will take better care of the weak batteries of Windows laptops. PCMark 8 runs production tests up to complete discharge Battery:

In all three tests I ran, Windows 10 ran 9 minutes longer. Honestly, I would like more, but thanks for that.

Winner: Windows 10

8. Battery life (games)

When we "cut" into something very interesting, not only time flies by very quickly, but also the battery charge. Unfortunately, even with the current driver from NVIDIA, when playing GTA V, the operating time in the top ten was reduced, all tests show a decent “minus” of 13 percent:

Winner: Windows 8.1

9. Battery life (movies)

When watching a 1080p video clip through Windows Media Player on Windows 8.1 laptop shut down after 2 hours and 25 minutes. In Windows 10, this figure turned out to be much better - 3 hours, or + 25%. Apparently, the "ten" is more rationally related to such a scenario of use - background activity is minimized, only the video player works "seriously":

Winner: Windows 10.

The final score is 2: 7 not in favor of Windows 8.1.

Verdict

Windows 10, even at the very beginning of its life cycle, is already faster than Windows 8.1. But miracles do not happen: in the winning scenarios for the "dozen" use cases, the increase in speed is most often minimal, significant progress has been achieved only in terms of video viewing. Also, let's not forget that the tests were carried out on a "clean" version of the system, Windows with a large number of installed games, programs and drivers will run much slower over time.

And how (faster, slower) does Windows 10 work for you, dear readers? Share your opinion in the comments!

Which Windows is better than 7 or 10 - this question is raised by many users, because before reinstalling the operating system, it is not always completely clear which of these versions will be the most acceptable. Disputes about the choice of this or that OS most likely will not stop for a long time, and everyone finds their own advantages among these versions. Let's try to figure out about all the advantages, disadvantages, performance of the "seven" and "ten".

Virtually all Microsoft operating system users have migrated from one stable release to the next. XP was considered the most successful and functional in its time. The appearance of Vista did not impress many people, first of all, because it had many shortcomings and bugs that were not fixed even due to the release of patches and updates. The developers themselves, realizing all the shortcomings of the newly minted OS, began to develop a conceptually new operating system, as a result of which Windows 7 appeared in 2009, which really turned out to be stable and practical to use.

Evolution from "seven" to "ten"

After some time, the specialists of the OS Windows developer company felt the need to create an improved operating system, the graphical shell of which was as similar as possible to the one that began to be implemented in mobile devices... This was primarily due to the fact that to enter the market with a new mobile platform, which would compete with Android and iOS in the mobile platform market, and, accordingly, bring the desktop version as close as possible to the mobile one.

However, the majority of users did not like this decision, and the 8th version, in fact, like Vista, did not gain such popularity as XP and the "seven" had before. As a result, the developers made a "Solomon" decision - to combine mobile version with the classic desktop, which ultimately led to the emergence of Windows 10.

In terms of performance and functionality, this release was noticeably better than the 8th version.

Let's figure out what is the difference between Windows 7 and 10, and which version will satisfy more certain requirements.

Comparative characteristics of the "seven" and "ten"

All testing will be done on a computer with the following characteristics:

• processor core i5 3.4GHz;
• RAM 8 Gb;
• Video GeForce 980 GTX;
• HDD 1Tb.

1. Loading and unloading speed of operating systems

Turning on the computer, and, accordingly, the temporary OS boot parameter in these two versions is actually the same: 5 sec. at 7 versus 6 sec. the 10th version.

But as regards the exit from sleep mode, here the latest version is clearly superior to the previous one and has a significantly lower indicator. If it takes only 10 seconds for a full shutdown at 10, then 7 to 17. That is, this indicator differs almost twofold. The same applies to exiting the hypernation mode (the difference is also about 7 seconds).

1. Appearance and a graphical interface.

Comparing the design of two objects is always a subjective thing, because each of the people has his own taste and vision. Before comparing these two operating systems, it must be said that the transition of the user from the "seven" to the "ten" will be quite painful, because in some graphical aspects, the operating systems data differ dramatically.

The design of the 10th version is made in a strict direction: flatness and sharpness of the corners. Windows 7, on the other hand, is more familiar to those who have been using this OS as the main one on their computer for more than a dozen years. It all depends on the specific taste of the person himself.

The top ten has a choice of desktop display: classic and in the form of a tile, which was introduced in the 8th version. This parameter can be attributed to more new version, as there is no such choice at all in the seven. The Start menu in 7 is also more familiar, but in 10 it is presented as a hybrid of classic and tiles.

In general, we can note the fact that the "ten" looks much more colorful and prettier than its predecessor. If we take into account the fact that there is a voice assistant here, then in the parameter of the graphical shell, Windows 10 attracts much more.

Performance of programs and games

At startup Microsoft office, the software is loaded in approximately the same amount of time. No significant differences were found here.

When testing work Mozilla browsers and Chrome, the "seven" has proven itself much better. The loading speed, as well as the display of pages, is much faster here. It should be noted that the new Edge browser, which is installed only on 10-ku, is generally not inferior in response time to the aforementioned browsers on the 7-ka, but this question is subjective, since there is simply no such application in 7-ka.

With regards to working with hard drives in general, then throughput, the speed of copying to different sections is approximately the same.

From the use of new modern toys, we can say that they work in about the same way. When comparing the performance of Crysis 3, the fps values ​​did not actually differ, although this parameter was still higher in the 10th version. The only thing is that in a more modern version of the operating system, difficulties may arise with the launch of those games that came out even before the appearance of the "seven": they simply cannot be installed.

conclusions

Based on the above, we can say that if you plan to purchase Windows OS, then the choice of course should fall on the 10th version. If on this moment you have a "seven" installed, then you shouldn't bother too much and rush to switch to a more modern version, because from the above we can say that two separate products are approximately the same.

In contact with

Which is better: Windows 10 or Windows 8.1 or Windows 7?

More and more users are switching to Windows 10. Latest version operating room Microsoft systems, attracts not only by its novelty, but also by its undemandingness - the OS works great even on not the most powerful computers.

In order to verify this, we tried to install Windows 10 on several computers of different configurations at once, and compare their performance - clean installation vs. clean install. Our tests show that moving to Windows 10 will save Windows 7 and Windows 8 users several gigabytes. disk space, several tens of megabytes of RAM, and a few seconds of boot time.

Windows 10 vs. Windows 7

We used four system configurations in our testing, most of which are already obsolete and not so fast. For example, the Dell Latitude E6410 is a mid-range Windows 7 laptop sold in 2010, while the HP Stream Mini and Stream 11 are modern budget models running cheap Windows 8.1 with Bing. To oppose budget solutions, our test also features a powerful modern laptop from 2015, the Dell XPS 13. Full specifications tested machines are presented below in a small table.

We measured the disk space occupied by Windows 7 before and after installing all updates (64-bit Windows 7 from MSDN was taken as an example of a "clean" installation). Even if you delete all Windows update files, all restore points and cached files, a patched Windows 7 installer will use about 10 GB more disk space than an unpatched one. It is not so critical if you have HDD 500 GB, but do not forget about the popular SSD media, the volume of which is often 128 or 256 GB.

Windows 10 uses less disk space in both cases: savings of 5-6 GB with a basic installation of the OS, and 15-16 GB with a fully patched installation operating system... Of course, it is quite possible that in three or four years the Windows 10 installation distribution will also be "overgrown" with all sorts of updates, and this will bring it closer to its predecessors in terms of disk space occupied, but we hope that this problem will be solved due to the same system disk compression, which is now successfully used in the new OS.

It is very difficult to correctly estimate the amount of RAM used, since each separately taken OS behaves in its own way, and the set of programs used on a PC has a much greater impact on the load of RAM than all the improvements in Windows 10 combined. However, lounging behind the monitor screen, on which the OS is installed with all the updates, you involuntarily notice that Windows 10 still uses a little less RAM than Windows 7. And this despite the fact that Windows 10 has full antivirus support in Windows Defender whereas Windows 7 only had simple malware protection.

Most striking (especially for Windows users 7) an increase in the speed of loading a new OS. Note that the foundation for this was laid back in Windows 8 - with booting Windows 7 every time the operating system and user session are fully loaded from the disk drive. Booting Windows 8 is most suitable for the definition of "hibernation mode": the OS kernel is moved from RAM to disk drive when turned off, and when turned on, the procedure is repeated exactly the opposite.

As a result, loading times are noticeably reduced. So, OS boot time for Stream Mini nettop equipped with SSD storage, has almost halved. Whereas, the E6410 laptop booted up 14 seconds faster compared to Windows 7.

Windows 10 vs. Windows 8.1 with Bing

Inexpensive computer systems the likes of Steam 11 and Steam Mini are often sold with “Windows 8.1 with Bing”. In terms of functionality, such an operating system is no different from standard Windows 8.1 Home Edition, however it costs less for OEM PC makers due to the fact that they agree to install it by default. Internet browser Explorer search engine Bing (the end user can change this option).

Both operating systems use a different but related option to compress Windows when installed to disk, which is named WIMBoot. The WIMBoot bootloader is the original version of the compression system used by Windows 10 to reduce the amount of disk space it takes up - your OS boots from a compressed image Windows file(eng. Windows image file), which is usually stored separately at the end of the disk. The same part of the disk can be used for system recovery.

The WIMBoot loader has one big drawback: all files that are compressed Windows image cannot be updated by the operating system. In such a situation, if an update occurs, you will have two copies of the same file at once: a compressed copy within the image, and an uncompressed, updated copy. That is why the Center Windows Updates Provides only critical and security updates for operating systems with WIMBoot. Windows 10 has deprecated image-based compression for such system files so the problem with duplicate files ceased to exist.

If you remove all the pre-installed HP junk on the Stream Mini nettop, basic setting Windows 8.1 with Bing will take up 8.8 GB of the main system partition, plus 6.72 GB of the WIMBoot image for a total of 15.52 GB. If you install all the updates additionally, then the system partition will occupy 22.1 GB, while the same 6.72 GB of the partition occupied by WIMBoot.

Microsoft improves and optimizes every product. Each new version of the operating Windows systems has a number advantages or disadvantages before the previous product, but each time a new OS is different its shell and the presence of new options.

It is impossible to say which version of the operating system is better: each software is different decent performance and versatility indicators. Most people like the old Windows builds with a comfortable and well-established design, but they are devoid of Microsoft support programs, unlike the new ones, which are improving every day based on user feedback.

Comparing Windows 7 and 10: What's the Difference

Despite the peak in popularity of Windows 10, many users remain loyal to the Seven. Windows 7 has:

• habitual design and convenient location of all options,
• recovery center and stable performance,
• easy software filling that does not load the processor.

Most users prefer the seventh OS, but if the "seven" is significantly ahead of the eight in functionality and performance, then Windows 10 is serious competitor winning in many parameters. In addition to fast performance and ease of management, "ten", in contrast to Windows 7, has:

• light system backup and recovery center,
• constant upgrade and shell optimization,
• work with the latest drivers and application support,
• support DirectX 12 and Microsoft Edge.

Despite the widespread popularity of Windows 7, the OS is obsolete a variant that is gradually losing its former multifunctionality and quality of work. If the user appreciates convenience location functionality"Sevens" and old design then Windows 7 is a great choice. This OS fit for people of the third age or old school - those for whom the convenience of work is more important productivity.

Windows 7 or 8: version features

These operating systems are very similar in appearance, however, Windows 7 has a larger potential and the best performance as well as a comfortable and familiar design. According to statistics, users do not have a choice between version 7 and 8, many return to the "seven" after Windows testing 8.

Windows 8 did not become a breakthrough in the computer manufacturing industry like 7 or 10. This operating system has inconvenient desktop, start menu, and item layout. The G8 was originally aimed at the operation of mobile devices and one should not expect any special performance in games or general performance from this OS. OS is tailored for work on touch gadgets, as well as increased energy efficiency, and on stationary PCs may not be as comfortable as the counterparts of the seventh or tenth version.

Which is better - Windows 8 or 10

Windows 10 is multifunctional: it will be convenient to use the OS both on a stationary PC and on mobile platforms. Choosing the tenth version, you get wide-profile and a stable operating system with a wide range of functions and additional configurations. Windows 10 is the most demanded an operating system that only gets better every day. "Ten" allows:

• use new Microsoft browser Edge,
• work with several virtual tables,
• use option analysis disk space,
• enjoy notification center,
• launch games for Xbox One.

Microsoft invests more resources to support and optimize version 10, which is the most demanded and popular version after the gradually dying "seven". The eighth version is made to work mobile platforms is based on Windows and has a number of disadvantages in the interface: it is difficult to get used to the OS and master the basic functions, which is significant distinguishes Figure eight from 10 and 7 versions.

So what to choose

To receive you need to best performance and the ability to use all available configurations, recommended fulfill clean install operating system. Installing Windows through updates significantly degrades performance computer and may cause some drivers or applications to malfunction.

It is believed that each subsequent version of Windows is better than the previous one: in new versions improves and the software is rotated and the performance of the operating system is improved. However, ordinary users, to whom a slight increase in power will not give special advantages, choose the OS based on their own comfort of using the software. The choice of an operating system is a matter of habit and in many respects it all depends on the nature of the user.

So, let's try to quickly deal with perhaps the main "computer" questions of recent months: which is better - Windows 10 or Windows 8.1?

Negative changes

Speaking about what to choose, it is worth first considering those OS features that were missing in the new version. First of all, you will not find a snap function, or rather, it has changed so much that it may not seem entirely convenient to many. Now you cannot securely dock the metro application to the edge of the desktop so that it cannot be closed by other windows.

There are other features as well. You should decide how lazy you are to make a few clicks in order to return the OS to its usual form. In particular, by default, metro-applications are launched in windows and they will have to be expanded, and secondly, "Start" now does not open in full screen, but this can be fixed with one click.

This is how the Start Menu looked like, aka the desktop in Windows 8

But in Windows 10, the "Start" menu returned to a more standard form.

Positive changes

Firstly, now the interface has ceased to be so fragmented - all applications work in a single space and there is no need to constantly switch between the classic and modern desktop modes.

However, if you liked this feature, then do not forget to rate new opportunity creating desktops - many will find it very successful.

Finally, among the pluses, one can also name the fact that all applications will work equally well regardless of which operating system you choose - Windows 8 or Windows 10. Perhaps the absence of a snap is the only minus that users previous version will be able to notice in the top ten.

Already now you can evaluate the new product.