Sound cards creative x fi characteristics. Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook sound card review. Installing drivers and utilities

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Introduction

The X-Fi Surround 5.1 sound card is housed in a nice, compact black case with a large rotating handle, and a lot of interesting things are hidden inside. You shouldn't be alarmed by the lack of control keys, since the package includes a very functional remote control, which we'll talk about later. The connection to the PC is carried out via the classic USB 2.0 interface, so compatibility with all modern computers. Of course, taking into account the rather high requirements for the computer, especially under Vista.

Manufacturer Creative
Interface USB 2.0
Sampling frequency 96 kHz
Bit depth 24 bits
Inputs
On the map Linear, microphone
Exits
On the map 2 "tulips" + 2 mini-jacks (5.1), 1 S/PDIF optical, 1 headphones
DVD and cinema
Standards S/PDIF output, Power DVD support
Configuration Up to 5.1
3D sound in games
Standards EAX 4.0, OpenAL, Creative Alchemy
Configuration 2 and 5.1
MIDI
Synthesizer No
Minimum configuration
Windows XP SP2 Pentium 4 1.6 GHz or AMD Athlon XP 2000+, 512 MB memory
Windows Vista Intel Core 2 Duo 2.0 GHz, AMD Athlon 64 Dual Core or equivalent, 1 GB memory

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Inputs and outputs

The Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 sound card is clearly aimed at digital entertainment, namely listening to music and watching movies, so you have to make do with the necessary inputs and outputs for these areas. The weak point is that the inputs are limited to the usual 3.5mm mini-jacks for microphone and line-in. There is no digital input. The outputs are richer, there is a 5.1 output, where the left and right front speakers are connected via “tulips”, which will please Hi-Fi lovers. There is also a 3.5mm mini-jack adapter, which should satisfy everyone. And the rear speakers and center/subwoofer are connected via regular 3.5 mm mini-jacks. There is also a digital optical output S/P DIF, allowing you to connect a receiver or home theater.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Drivers and software

Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 included software, which is well known to owners of X-Fi cards and other Creative products. There's nothing new in this regard, except that some features of high-end X-Fi sound cards are not available. Thus, Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 only works in the “Entertainment” mode; game and music creation modes are not available. However, audio processing features such as X-Fi Crystalizer or CMSS3D surround sound are available and can be controlled using the remote control.


The sound card's mixer is very limited; when recording, you can only adjust the level.



We found a regular X-Fi card panel with access to different systems sound processing.



There are also several options available for the remote control.


To configure, you can use the Audio Console in the Windows Control Panel.


Many Creative software features are accessed through the volume icon in the tray.



A Media Center-style interface is available, but we weren't interested in it.

Following in the tradition of the latest Creative products, you can download the PowerDVD player for free, which will allow you to decode Dolby Digital and DTS. For Vista gamers, Creative has included the Alchemy program, which will allow you to enjoy sound effects despite the change in the sound processing subsystem in Windows. However, X-Fi 5.1 Surround, like all USB cards, is not aimed at gamers.

It should be noted that the sound card, like many new models, is capable of running under Windows XP or Vista without installing drivers. If you can be content with the simplest functions, you can connect a sound card without changing anything in the system. Of course, if you want to get the most out of Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1, you'll have to install drivers and software.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Test configuration

Test configuration.

  • Processor: Pentium 4 2.4 GHz;
  • memory: 1 GB DDR;
  • video card: nVidia GeForce Ti 4200;
  • hard drive: 80 GB 7,200 rpm;
  • optic DVD drive LG 16/48x;
  • OS: XP SP3;
  • DirectX version: 9.0c.

Columns.

  • Creative Gigaworks S750, Logitech Z2200.

Playing video.

  • Power DVD.

Measurements.

  • Right Mark Audio Analyzer 6.0.6;
  • DAAS sound measurement system.

The tests were carried out through recording/playback (input and output were connected), and it could be expected that the recording system was of lower quality than the playback system. Therefore, we conducted separate playback tests, where a professional E-MU 1616m sound card was used for recording.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Test results: 16 bits, 44.1 kHz


Frequency response unevenness: almost ideal characteristic for these parameters.

Noise level: Very low, close to the theoretical maximum that can be expected at these settings.

Nonlinear distortion: very low, so there will be no problems.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Test results: 24 bit, 48 kHz

Frequency response unevenness: Frequency response goes up to 24 kHz without much attenuation. One could hardly wish for more.

Noise level: The frequency band is wider, the noise is felt more strongly, but remains at a very low level.

Nonlinear distortion: Distortion is still very low.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Test results: 24 bit, 96 kHz


Frequency response unevenness: We get 30 kHz at -0.5 dB and 40 kHz at -2 dB! One can hardly wish for more...

Noise level: The noise level is still very low.

Nonlinear distortion: distortions in practice are very low.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Test results: 24 bit, 96 kHz (playback)


Frequency response unevenness: Frequency response reaches 20 kHz with very little attenuation.

Noise level: The noise level does not exceed 100 dB, which is simply excellent for a sound card at this price.

Nonlinear distortion: Distortion is very low.

As tests have shown, the quality of the sound card is very good, without any weak points. This is not to say that it cannot be better, but X-Fi Surround 5.1 provides ample quality for all target use cases: if the quality is unsatisfactory, then other elements in the playback chain will be to blame. In practice, we were quite satisfied with our test listening equipment. The quality was not satisfactory; X-Fi processing improved the sound from most sources.

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1 | Conclusion

The X-Fi Surround 5.1 sound card is sold at a very affordable price of 70 euros (at the time of publication it had not yet arrived in Russia). At the same time, it provides unpretentious but high-quality surround sound, both on a laptop and on a desktop PC. Considering that laptops are often equipped with not the highest quality integrated sound, we have a very interesting option. However, the main obstacle will be high system requirements, especially under Vista.

Advantages.

  • Very good quality sound;
  • works in basic mode without installing drivers;
  • PowerDVD player included.

Flaws.

  • High system requirements.

We spent a lot of time with Creative's latest sound card, the X-Fi. Although outwardly it looks like an ordinary sound PCI card, the model features a completely new and improved filling. So there is something to pay attention to. In this article, we have collected all the experience gained throughout the year when we tested preliminary versions. In addition, we recommend that you read the two previous articles on X-Fi technology.

As the Steel Was Tempered

Creative sound cards have evolved since the release of the first model, the Sound Blaster PRO in 1991, which provided 8-bit audio. It was followed by the famous AWE 32 and Live!, and then the Audigy line, which was the de facto standard for sound cards until today. X-Fi cards represent a huge leap forward in power and digital audio processing capabilities. The evolution can be clearly traced in the following table.

Sound card Pure MIPS MIPS value for average processor Internal audio channels Normalization factor in MIPS number relative to Live! Number of simultaneous real-time effects Number of transistors
Sound Blaster Pro ?1 3+ - 0.0001x - 100 000
AWE 32 (EMU8000) 67 200+ - 0.2x - 500 thousand
Live! (10k1) 335 1000+ 16
1x 1 2 million
Audigy (10k2) 424 1250+ 64
(in relation to the effects engine)
4x 4 4.6 million
Creative X-Fi 10340 30000+ 4096
(to all processing elements)
67x 8 51.1 million

Notes

  • Net MIPS: The number of addition instructions multiplied by the execution frequencies that can be applied to the signal data. This does not include any operations that a typical processor must additionally perform to process the signal data.
  • MIPS value for the average processor: an assumption of the computing requirements imposed on a typical processor in 1998, when the Live! line was launched. As expected, a typical processor from 1998 could be programmed to perform the same functions as Live!, Audigy or X-Fi chips. Such processors do not execute all algorithms efficiently. Therefore, to perform the same tasks as Live!, Audigy or X-Fi, they have to provide more power in MIPS. The difference can be 3x.
  • More information about the measurements given can be found at Creative website .

It should be emphasized that Creative, unlike most competitors, has always installed a real sound processor on its cards, and did not use a simplified codec that loads the CPU. This approach gives cards superiority in games, where Creative was able to free up additional CPU resources for audio, but leads to disadvantages in other areas. Processors used in Live! and Audigy, operate at the “native” frequency of 48 kHz, which creates some problems when working at 44.1 kHz, and you can completely forget about processing higher sampling rates. With the release of X-Fi, all these problems are gone: digital processing is now available for any available sample rates.

X-Fi is not just a new chip. Unlike traditional audio processing chips, which have a fixed serial architecture, the X-Fi Audio Ring architecture provides any processing sequence needed for a given application. That is, X-Fi has a true modular architecture, with each module connected to an Audio Ring - a kind of highway through which up to 4096 audio channels can pass.

But it hardly makes sense to compare the Audio Ring backbone with a professional mixer, since it supports much larger number capabilities - such as communication with PC memory via a PCI interface with a fairly high bandwidth.

The following table shows the distribution of the processing power of the X-Fi chip across the main modules. We will look at some modules in detail, for example, the same Sample Rate Converter (SRC), new technology, which, as you will see, takes the lion's share of the computing power.

Pure MIPS
Sample Rate Converter (SRC) 7310
Filter 200
Mixer 1210
Storage (Tank) 440
DSP 1180
Total 10340

In practice, X-Fi card users are offered three configurations corresponding to three types of tasks: games (Gaming), entertainment (Entertainment) and music creation (Creation). The following table lists the main features of each configuration, which we will look at in more detail in the drivers and software section.

In addition, it should be separately noted that the X-Fi chip is not tied to the USB bus: it can be used with USB, FireWire or PCI Express interfaces. It is quite possible to expect the release of special versions of the chip for the consumer electronics sector.

We are waiting for the simultaneous release of four X-Fi cards that will satisfy the needs and desires of different categories of users. The X-Fi XtremeMusic card can be considered a basic model, designed for listening to music, entertainment (DVDs and games), as well as for other not particularly complex uses. You will receive a PCI card without any extras. Directly accessible interfaces (1/8" mini-jacks only) are limited to the FlexiJack input (which can be used as a microphone input, line input or optical S/PDIF input) and speaker outputs. The latter, understandably, support 7.1 acoustics, as well as three mini-jacks of previous Creative 7.1 cards. Please note that the stereo output (the first mini-jack) can be used as a headphone jack. The card has an interface for connecting an external module, if you suddenly want to upgrade. The card itself contains an additional one. input, as well as another expansion connector for connecting an internal module. In addition, on the card you can find an expansion interface of Creative’s own format, the purpose of which is not yet known to us.

The next model, X-Fi Platinum, has all the characteristics of the base card (in fact, both cards look identical), but in the package you will receive an internal module for the 5.25" bay. The module has a line / microphone input with level adjustment (1 /4" jack), line-in, digital optical and coaxial inputs and outputs, and a headphone jack with volume control. There you will also find MIDI interfaces (mini-DIN). The delivery set includes adapters for standard MIDI connectors. In addition, we note the presence of an IR remote control remote control. In general, all the listed functions allow us to recommend this card to fans who like a large number of interfaces and easy access to them.

The more specialized Fatal1ty FPS model is very close to the Platinum, including a PCI card and internal module, but is aimed at hardcore gamers. The board has 64 MB of additional memory (X-RAM), which allows for increased performance in games that support this technology.

Finally, we move on to the top-end model, the X-Fi Elite Pro, which consists of a PCI card and an external module, which is quite large and supports both vertical and horizontal installation using the included rack. Of course, the user will also receive a remote control. Our testing will be based, for the most part, on this model. Additionally, we'll be looking at it in more detail because of the high-quality transducers that make the card deliver the best sound quality.

The remote control comes with all versions except the basic XtremeMusic. It allows you to control a number of functions like Crystalizer, EAX, CMSS-3D and 3DMIDI, and also allows you to play files and make important adjustments like volume. On the Elite Pro external module, you can access the same adjustments using rotary functions - very convenient. In addition, the functions of the knobs display illuminated indicators, so it is difficult to make mistakes.

Creative Labs X-Fi Elite Pro
Interface PCI
Main chip CA20K1 (X-Fi)
Max. sampling frequency 192 kHz
Quantization 24 bits
ASIO 24 bit/96 kHz
Inputs
On the map Microphone/line/digital SP/DIF with adapter, line Molex (on the board itself)
On the external module Linear Hi-Z, Mic/Line, Headphones/Line, Optical and Coaxial S/PDIF
Exits
On the map 8 for acoustics (7.1), 1 optical and coaxial S/PDIF (mini-jack)
On the external module 1 optical and coaxial S/PDIF, 1 adjustable microphone
DVD and cinema
Standards Dolby Digital EX, DTS-ES, S/PDIF output
Configuration Up to 7.1
DVD Audio Yes
3D sound in games
Standards DS3D, A3D, Open AL, EAX 5.0
Configuration From 2 to 7.1
MIDI
Software synthesizer Creative SoundFounds 24 bit
Enter exit Standard Prices (DIN)

The PCI card is equipped with one input (1/8", 3.5 mm mini-jack) called FlexiJack, which can be configured via the driver to act as a line input, microphone input or digital interface (input and output). On the external module Elite Pro has a ton of interfaces. The front panel is equipped with two 1/4" (6.35 mm) input jacks with level adjustment. The first, depending on the position of the control knob, can serve as either a line input or a high-impedance (Hi-Z) input, the most practical use for which would be to connect musical instruments such as an electric guitar. The second input is more standard - it can be used as a line or microphone.

Behind there is another entrance on the "tulips". Using a small switch, it can be configured as a line input or turntable input (phono) with RIAA correction. Great idea - now you can listen to your vinyl record collection and easily digitize it. Please note that the player's ground should also be connected - this detail is often forgotten...

Add to this optical and coaxial digital S/PDIF inputs, as well as a pair of “tulips” for MIDI input and output. Finally, we note the special connector for Creative speakers.

If you look at the possible connections, Creative's commitment to consumer-grade equipment becomes clear - there is no, say, balanced input. However, the set of ports is quite complete: microphone, line-in and headphones, plus added connectivity musical instrument via a simple standard cable. So the card design will fully satisfy the needs of amateurs.

There's nothing particularly noteworthy about the X-Fi PCI card. In general, in appearance it can easily be confused with any other Creative model. It is interesting to note that the X-Fi chip (CA20K1) turned out to be much more compact than the same Audigy chip. There will be two different cards in the X-Fi line. The Elite Pro version uses Cirrus Logic CS4398 D/A converters (192 kHz, 120 dB) and AKM AK5394 A/D converter (192 kHz, 123 dB). The second version of the PCI card for less expensive models is equipped with Cirrus Logic CS4382 digital-to-analog converters (192 kHz, 114 dB) and a Wolfson WM8775 chip, which contains a mixer for four analog sources and an analog-to-digital converter (96 kHz, 102 dB).

The Elite Pro external module uses TI Burr-Brown PCM1804 analog-to-digital converters (192 kHz, 111 dB). The headphone jack uses a Cirrus Logic CS4392 digital-to-analog converter (192 kHz, 114 dB). The bottom line is very simple: the best line-in input is provided by the Elite Pro PCI card. However, the inputs on the module are of sufficient quality for most applications.

Of the various blocks that make up the X-Fi architecture, the Sample Rate Converter (SRC) may seem the most mysterious and the least interesting to most users. But pay attention to the table at the beginning of the article: it uses the largest share of computing power! To understand the importance of this block, let us delve a little deeper into the nature of digital audio.

The sampling rate corresponds to the number of times per second that the signal is read. For example, for conventional audio CDs it is 44,100 times per second (Hertz, Hz). Today the frequency range has become wider - it all depends on the source (the same DVD or DVD-Audio). In addition, even sources with the same theoretical value can differ significantly, since in practice the frequency does not always exactly match the theory. When mixing multiple sources, this frequency spread can lead to noticeable sound defects. Professional equipment used in studios uses synchronization systems that consumer solutions do not have. Interaction between different types of equipment is an even more complex issue. Converting sample rates could solve all the problems, but until now it was considered a workaround. In some cases - at least in the fundamental essence of the work - conversion can degrade the quality of the signal, especially if not very much computing power is spent on it.

However, for SRC Creative used a new architecture that makes sound signal completely transparent. Converting the 997-Hz test signal from 44.1 to 48 kHz resulted in distortion of -136 dB and +0.00025 dB. That is, the distortion and noise are less than what other audio components can provide, so you can guarantee that there will be no artifacts associated with the conversion.

Digital signal processing from 44.1 kHz to 48 kHz using SRC.

Level of distortion and noise (THD+N, distortion + noise) when converting from 44.1 to 48 kHz. You simply have no chance of noticing this transition!

SRC is not only a technical achievement, but also a tool that allows the X-Fi card to deliver the quality it promises in many areas. The first advantage is the synchronization of digital signals, but you can also create effects like environment or motion, with much higher accuracy than any consumer equipment that existed before X-Fi.

With SRC you can easily and accurately create the Doppler effect!

The working principle of traditional digital synchronization.

X-Fi digital synchronization is carried out entirely by the SRC unit.

Finally, SRC allows savings in areas such as audio synthesis, particularly in storing samples for music playback. The block allows you to transparently transform a small number of samples to output a wide range of notes, adjusting parameters such as pitch and vibrato.

As we noted above, X-Fi cards support three operating modes: entertainment (Entertainment, for tasks like listening to music or watching DVDs), games (Games) and audio creation (Audio Creation, sound and music). The Mode Switcher allows you to select any of them, and the card configuration changes to give the best quality in the selected area. In addition, the set of functions and control panel also depend on the selected mode. Below is a table showing all this.

The Mode Switcher allows you to select one or another level of card functions that best suits the required area. It only takes a few seconds to configure the X-Fi card.

Entertainment Audio Creation Games
3DMIDI playback Yes Yes Yes
Working with 3DMIDI No Yes No
EAX ADVANCED HD 5.0 Limited Limited Yes
EAX ADVANCED HD 4.0 Limited Limited Yes
EAX ADVANCED HD 3.0 Yes Yes Yes
Number of auxiliary effects 2 4 4
Max. number of reverberations 1 2 4
Effects on Input Sources No 4 No
ASIO Output Channels: Dry 1 pair 5 pairs 1 pair
ASIO Output Channels: FX No 4 pairs No
ASIO Input Channels: WUH 8 8 8
ASIO Input Channels: Basic 2 (1 pair) 2 (1 pair) 2 (1 pair)
ASIO 2.0 support Limited Yes Limited
ASIO 2.0 direct monitoring 0 12 (6 pairs) 0
Bit-Matched playback No Yes No
Bit-Matched entry No Yes No
CMSS-3DSurround Yes No Yes
CMSS-3DHeadphone (headphones) Yes No Yes
CMSS-3DVirtual (2 columns) Yes No Yes
CMSS-3DVirtual (4 columns) No No Yes
CMSS-3DInteractive Yes Yes Yes
Crystalizer 24 bit Yes Yes Yes
Graphic equalizer 10 stripes 10 stripes 10 stripes
Smart Volume Management Yes Yes Yes
Bass Management Advanced No Advanced

In Entertainment mode, you will get a screen that resembles music Center, with several windows allowing you to adjust numerous functions. Among them there are both well-known windows and those that are not particularly different (at least in appearance) from the old Creative cards - the same 10-band equalizer, mixer and speaker settings. Other windows are completely new - like Crystalizer, or are completely redesigned old options - like CMSS. A little later we will look at the mentioned functions in detail.

In Entertainment mode, the control panel resembles a stereo system.

The mixer can be called classic.

Here we get the well-known equalizer from early Creative cards, whose capabilities are identical to previous versions.

No surprises with the choice of speaker configuration. Using a listening test, you can check their correct placement.

In Game mode we get a very compact screen with many of the settings mentioned above, but game-specific functions also appear here. The mixer panel allows you to enable EAX effects, as well as adjust ambience effects for the microphone. Plus, you'll get a more powerful version of EAX: 5.0!

For games, you can turn on EAX effects and change your voice by processing the signal coming from the microphone.

Creation mode is a completely different world. Here it is better to be familiar with professional music equipment. On the screen you will get a mixer with advanced features. We will not dwell on them in detail, since they are very extensive, and at the time of writing this article we do not have detailed information. Help in the software is very sparse, but the presence of buses and inputs/outputs for user binding gives very interesting opportunities. For example, you can map any input to any output, or assign mixed audio to one or more outputs. It seems to us that such opportunities will appeal to many people, including DJs.

For musicians, in addition to a wide palette of effects, an important new feature will be the 3D MIDI function, which makes it very easy to position MIDI sound in space - this new opportunity easily accessible even for amateurs! Of course, the sound creation mode opens the door to ASIO 2.0 support and allows you to freely choose the sample rate among the standard values. If you select 96 kHz, the effects selection menu doesn't disappear, unlike previous Creative cards. With X-Fi, all effects work regardless of the selected frequency. But be careful: the files can become large!

In Creation mode, you can send stereo audio to eight 7.1 channels. This interesting feature will appeal to some users.

You can add parametric equalization to an input to correct a bad sound source or apply an effect.


The reverb tab is pleasing to the eye. However, it may scare some users away.

Thanks to the support of 3D MIDI technology, the MIDI source can be freely positioned in space. We think this feature allows musicians to create some very interesting effects.

You can freely choose any standard frequency sampling!

The diagram allows you to understand the principle of card mixing. Unfortunately, it is only partial, but it gives an idea of ​​how to control and add effects.

There are so many options available in Creation mode that it would be impossible to talk about each of them in detail. For example, there are 24-bit SoundFonts, as well as the ability to work with ASIO 2.0 drivers with very low latency (2 ms). Although X-Fi is not aimed specifically at musicians, they will find some very interesting features.

Among the X-Fi modules, one can note Crystalizer, which operates in three modes. We have already described its essence in detail in previous article about X-Fi, so we won’t repeat ourselves.

The Crystalizer has only one adjustment, graduated in percentage. With the Elite Pro card, you can change the effect level using the remote control or directly on the external module. In general, we were hoping for more comprehensive adjustment functions, but Creative's main goal is ease of use.

During listening, the Crystalizer processing actually produces a more realistic sound that is closer to what you get at a real concert. The dynamics of the sound are significantly improved, and there is an impression of an expansion of the frequency response - of course, it is not, but the impression arises due to increased clarity of low frequencies and additional processing of the upper part of the sound spectrum. Of course, the effect of Crystalizer depends greatly on the type of sound being processed. It will be practically unnoticeable for sound whose level changes little. But recordings with a lot of percussive sounds and transitions will sound better. We took Various types music, and after Crystalizer we found it very difficult to get back to normal playback levels. It seemed to us that the sound regular card can be compared to a concert venue closed by a thick curtain.

It is quite clear that in order to obtain Crystalizer quality, the playback system (amplifier and speakers) must be appropriate. Speakers must reproduce increased dynamic range without distortion. In addition, you should adjust the level of Crystalizer operation to suit the type of music. It is hardly reasonable to set one level for techno and opera! And the level of Crystalizer operation should be set depending on the characteristics of the original recording.

Today, as more and more consumers become familiar with surround sound, pure stereo, although still the most common format, seems outdated. If you're used to listening to 5.1 surround sound (or better), the stereo will seem a little thin. In addition, it is hardly wise to use only two channels if your speakers are multi-channel.

CMSS technology, which Creative has been promoting for some time, was developed (like many other similar solutions) to solve the problem of distributing two channels into 5.1 or 7.1 surround sound. Until now, the result could not be called very successful. But thanks high power X-Fi this technology, which is called CMSS 3D, now gives much more best result. We described the operating principle of the technology in previous material .

In practice, the X-Fi version of CMSS 3D has several modes, depending on the type of equipment you have and the sound being processed. The first mode splits the stereo into 5.1 or 7.1, but the technology can also create virtual surround sound if you only have two speakers. Finally, the third mode significantly improves the listening experience on headphones, as we'll see below.

CMSS 3D technology is very effective at outputting stereo sound across multiple channels, adding both surround sound and preserving the center channel of the virtual stage. In a normal recording, the singer will be positioned exactly in the center of the sound space and will not "travel" around the stage due to inaccuracy in the recording or playback. On the other hand, as you might expect, decomposing stereo into several CMSS 3D channels does not provide the same quality that a full-fledged multi-channel source can provide. The card creates an effect, but does not perform magic. This becomes obvious if you listen to recordings that exist in two versions: like the Jean-Michel Jarre album Aero or Feels Like Home by Norah Jones. Of course, the reproduction of a surround environment can impress the listener - it all depends on the original recording. At the same time, old albums can sound completely new. Because they were not made in today's "sterile" studios, they contain environmental information that is very interesting to perceive when rendered realistically. This is especially true for all live recordings, such as opera.

The decomposition of stereo sound into several channels works great in films. Watch a DivX movie in stereo that you previously watched in Dolby Digital and you will be amazed. Of course, CMSS 3D cannot provide original spatial sound, but it comes very close!

For our testing, we transferred a DVD movie to DivX "Toy Story 2". The introductory video for this film is good example spatial sound. CMSS 3D technology copes with the placement of most rear sound sources on the right and left. The move to Dolby Digital has improved audio positioning accuracy. Particularly if the action starts from behind, say - moving from the back right to the front left. But Creative's decomposition is still very good - much better than Dolby Pro Logic II, which often makes the sound unnatural and never does a good job of outputting sound to the rear speakers. If you often watch DivX movies and also use your PC as a video player for your living room, then you won't forget X-Fi surround sound.


It makes sense that Creative MediaSource software is included in the package. We used it to enjoy a recording of an opera with CMSS 3D processing.

Of course, there is no problem with playing an initially multi-channel track - be it a Dolby Digital or DTS movie. CMSS 3D promises “surround” sound on just two speakers, but here the result was not so convincing. Of course, the sound image is much superior to stereo, but it does not reach the level of 5.1 or 7.1 acoustics. This processing will be fine if you only have two speakers, but we highly recommend upgrading to a multi-channel system for watching movies.

The third CMSS 3D mode is specifically designed for listening through headphones. Traditional headphones are indispensable, but they have a number of disadvantages. In particular, they cannot create a realistic sound stage. With headphones, the sound seems to come from the center of the head or sometimes from above. But sound is limited to the confines of the skull. With CMSS 3D Headphone mode, you can enjoy 3D sound on headphones too. The difference will not only be in the placement of the various sound sources, but also in what Creative Creative calls "externalization" - the creation of a believable sound stage.

Let me explain the principles behind positioning sound sources in headphones. There are three factors at work here: ITD (Interaural Time Difference), ILD (Interaural Level Difference) and HRTF filters, which rework the sound by adding reflections and refractions caused by your body, head and ear.

For stereo audio, CMSS 3D continues to extract environmental information from the recording to give the listener the feeling of being in the middle of the action. But, of course, this effect is more impressive with a multi-channel source (Dolby Digital or DTS movies), as well as in games. Headphones are no longer the punishment they used to be and provide their own listening pleasure. But, as it seemed to us, there is still room for improvement in the technology in the arrangement of the front and rear sources. However, let’s not be categorical - everything very much depends on individual perception. In addition, our personal feeling was that the sound sources were located too high, so it would be nice to add some “height” adjustment.

Test system and sound measurements

Our test system is unchanged and provides plenty of power for the X-Fi card. Please note that in order to install new cards, your PC must provide a certain level of power supply. If it is weak or of poor quality, then problems may arise, especially when working with additional modules. We encountered such problems on an ordinary consumer-level machine, which already had a lot of different hardware installed: it simply stopped booting due to a weak power supply.

Hardware
CPU Pentium 4 2.4 GHz
Memory 1 GB DDR
Graphics card nVidia GeForce Ti4200
HDD 80 GB, 7200 rpm
Optical storage DVD LG16/48X
OS Windows XP Pro SP2
Direct X version 9.0c
Columns Creative Gigaworks S750, Logitech Z2200
Playing video Power DVD, Win DVD
Measurements Right Mark Audio Analyzer 5.4, Right Mark 3DSound 1.24, DAAS audio measurement system, Neutrik 3337 audio measurement system

All tests were performed on the X-Fi Elite Pro card. As we mentioned above, the differences between this card and the three other models lie in the quality of the DAC and ADC. The table below shows the quality levels provided by different cards in the X-Fi line. As you'll see, the main difference is in the recording/playback tests, where we went from 112dB signal-to-noise ratio for the Elite Pro to 98dB for the other cards. When it comes to playback, the difference is less noticeable since only one converter (DAC) is used. As we indicated above, the best quality is the linear input located directly on the PCI card.

Model X-Fi Elite Pro Other
Playing digital audio Frequency response unevenness Lo -1dB Hi -1dB 46kHz Lo -1dB Hi -1dB 45kHz
Interpenetration of channels L-R: -112 dB
R-L: -112dB
L-R: -105 dB
R-L: -105dB
Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) 116 dB 109 dB
0,00% 0,00%
Line in/line out
Recording and playback
Frequency response unevenness Lo -1dB Hi -1dB 45 kHz Lo -1dB ~17 Hz
Hi -1dB 42KHz
Interpenetration of channels L-R: -106 dB
R-L: -106 dB
L-R: -86 dB
R-L: -86 dB
Signal to Noise Ratio (SNR) 112 dB 98 dB
Total Harmonic Distortion + Noise (THD+N) 0,00% 0,00%

Frequency response unevenness: the characteristic turned out to be perfectly linear throughout the spectrum!

Noise level: The noise level is very low and uniform.

Dynamic range: an excellent result if you take into account quantization!

Nonlinear distortion: very low (H3 about -110 dB!); one can hardly wish for better...

Intermodulation distortion: There are no problems here.

Interpenetration of channels: Increases slightly at the higher end of the spectrum, but the interference is still too low to have any impact on sound quality.

With 24-bit quantization and a 48 kHz sampling rate, the card begins to show its true capabilities. This mode is a good compromise between quality and file size. In fact, this is why it is often used in professional applications. Here we are watching better dynamics and signal-to-noise ratio.

  • : +0.01, -0.19 dB.
  • : 112.6 dB(A).
  • Distortions: 0,0005%.
  • Interpenetration of channels: 101.2 dB.

Frequency response unevenness: Frequency response expanded in the upper range but remained perfectly linear.

Noise level: 24-bit quantization shows the capabilities of the card - and very low level noise.

Dynamic range: The dynamic range has reached its possible limit considering other parameters!

Nonlinear distortion: Same level as 44 kHz mode. The lower noise level explains the difference in the graphs (THD+N).

Intermodulation distortion: very small, so you are unlikely to feel them.

Interpenetration of channels: in the upper part of the spectrum we observe a relative increase in channel interference interference, but in the lower part, below 1 kHz, it has disappeared from the graph altogether.

This mode corresponds to the highest possible quality, but in reality it gives a spectrum extension of up to 40 kHz with negligible attenuation (0.13 dB!). The rest of the specification is identical.

  • Frequency response (20 Hz - 20 kHz): +0.01, -0.13 dB.
  • Weighted signal-to-noise ratio: 112.4 dB(A).
  • Distortions: 0,0005%.
  • Interpenetration of channels: 100.3 dB.

Frequency response unevenness: Almost linear response up to 40 Hz without noticeable attenuation!

Dynamic range: the result is still great!

Nonlinear distortion: absolutely identical to the picture at 48 kHz - very low.

Intermodulation distortion: negligible...

Interpenetration of channels: Here the interference is slightly higher than at 48 kHz, which is due to the expansion of the frequency response.

Basically, the graphs speak for themselves: with X-Fi you don't even have to think about quality, since the card is capable of delivering better quality than any available audio source. Our tests confirmed the results published by Creative, with a few differences that can be attributed to the usual variation in the parameters of individual models tested. As we noted above, sound quality depends on many parameters. So they may give slightly different results.

Games are Creative's strong point - the company's cards have always been leaders in this area. It hardly needs reminding that only Creative cards support the latest versions of EAX, and sound processors allow you to remove most of the audio processing load from the CPU, leaving maximum resources for the game. X-Fi marks a new stage in gaming audio with processing power and advanced "virtual reality" features. To promote the new features, Creative enlisted the help of cyber-athlete Jonathan Wendel, known in the gaming world under the pseudonym "Fatal1ty." This is exactly the addition to the name that one of Creative's new cards, aimed at hardcore gamers, received.

Fatal1ty and Franco from Creative at the X-Fi event.

At the LAN party, it was possible to compete with Fatal1ty.

Fatal1ty is a champion of cyber games.

With the release of the X-Fi line, Creative introduces new standard EAX 5.0, which is capable of delivering 128 sources in 3D space with multi-channel transition. In addition, MacroFX technology allows you to control the proximity and blocking of effects. In principle, the standard is still at an early stage of development, since it does not yet fully exploit X-Fi's audio processing capabilities. But significant improvements await us in the future. EAX Voice technology allows you to process the voices of players using a microphone in real time and display them to others based on their location in the virtual gaming space. It provides even deeper immersion into the virtual world, which will further manifest itself in a multi-user environment.

Games and 3D, continued

For cards that might interest hardcore gamers (Fatal1ty FPS and Elite Pro models), Creative opted to add memory called X-RAM. This dedicated memory allows you to avoid wasting your PC's main memory on audio. The technology is able to add effects to the game without any impact on performance. Or improve performance when using compressed audio - it will not be decompressed during the game. Creative conducted tests on a modified version Unreal Tournament 2004. The graph below (

Two USB sound cards with high-quality DACs

In today's material we compare two interesting sound cards: Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi HD vs. Asus Xonar U7. These are two products that are close in price and capabilities, in which the emphasis was placed on high-quality converters. Moreover, both cards at the time of writing were on sale at a very low price, a little over 3 thousand rubles.

On the forum, the Asus Xonar U7 was called the “optimal choice” in absentia, based on a review of photographs and specifications. Many people completely in vain forget about the need to directly compare devices by sound. Most are also unable to correctly interpret measurement results.

Name

  • Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi HD
  • Asus Xonar U7

The Creative card has a confusing name, as it is not related to the X-Fi cards and is not related to the Titanium HD card. As a result, the card's release went unnoticed. This product is not known at all to anyone except some computer audio enthusiasts.

Asus Xonar U7 also has an unclear name. Quite old cards U1 and U3 are budget products with integrated sound quality. U7 has no relation to previous products in this series.

Price

  • Creative: 3700 rub.
  • Asus: 3100 rub.

The cards cost almost the same, the difference in absolute values ​​in price is not serious. More importantly, such an affordable price makes them interesting to a wide range of buyers. They have virtually no competitors among USB cards!

At the same time, the Asus card appeared quite recently. The manufacturer also reports that the Asus Xonar U7 Echelon Edition model will soon appear with an army camouflage paint job and more functional drivers.

The target audience

  • Creative: mass, audiophiles
  • Asus: mass, home cinema

The Creative model is a card with full-size TRS headphone and microphone connectors. Interestingly, there is a Phono input for digitizing vinyl, with grounding. It also works in normal linear input mode. THX and other proprietary processing are software only. For movies, there is an optical digital output for connecting a 5.1 receiver with a decoder.

You can connect 7.1 analog speakers to the Asus card using minijack connectors. The emphasis is on the included Dolby software. Digital output - combined, optical/coaxial. Both cards have a line input, but in the case of Asus the line input is combined with a microphone input, which is quite difficult to guess.

It remains a mystery why it was necessary to load both cards with so many functions and software in addition to a high-quality output. This inevitably blurs the audience and distracts from the main advantage of the cards, namely high-quality DAC. All the other dregs are available in abundance in almost any sound card. In the description of sound cards and in the design of the boxes, as they say, “you can’t see the forest for the trees.” It is not clear who will organize a 7.1 cinema around a computer or laptop - this is inconvenient and in practice unclaimed. Fortunately, the user does not overpay much for all these additional functions, since the price of the cards is very low.

Volume knob

  • Creative: Miniature metal volume knob with original location. There is a Mute function when you press the knob. Using the handle is not very convenient, since it is located very close to the surface of the table: the fingers are located in a very unusual position and slip over the surface.
  • Asus: The smooth handle is recessed into the body. Pressing the knob turns off the speakers in favor of the headphones and vice versa. It is inconvenient to use: considerable effort is required, otherwise the finger will slip. The recess for the finger is made for beauty - it is much easier to adjust by pressing your finger where there is no recess.

In both cases, a non-stop digital regulator is used. The ergonomics of the regulators are very conditional. Due to the combination of the functions of a regulator and a button, the Asus regulator plays quite noticeably. Many users would prefer to remove the button, but so that there is no backlash. Also, the recessed Asus regulator is easy to carry sound interface. In all other cases, this decision looks controversial.

Illuminations

  • Creative: blue LED on top panel
  • Asus: 3 signal LEDs on the top panel

The activity indicator on the Creative card lights up brighter. In principle, for most this will not be a problem. But we had a strong desire to seal it with duct tape so that it would not be an eyesore and would not be constantly visible in peripheral vision.

Headphone output location

  • Creative: front
  • Asus: front

Both cards have convenient connectors.

Filling

  • Creative: DSP Creative CA0189-2AG, 2-channel DAC AKM AK4396 (123 dB), 2-channel ADC CS5361 (114 dB).
  • Asus: DSP CM6632A, 2-channel DAC Cirrus Logic CS4398 (120 dB), 6-channel DAC Cirrus Logic CS4362A (114 dB), 2-channel ADC CS5361 (114 dB).

The contents of both cards are very interesting. And this is the main feature of the cards, against which everything else no longer interests anyone. The Cirrus Logic CS4398 DAC is considered a higher class than the AKM AK4396.

All Creative USB sound cards feature a proprietary CA0189-2AG RISC processor with a frequency of 100 MHz. Unlike the usual Creative DSPs, this chip does not have hardware audio processing. Its purpose is fast USB controller 2.0 and multi-channel interface to full-fledged I²S/I²C converter chips, such as those used by Cirrus Logic and AKM. There are two crystal oscillators soldered on the board.

Asus uses an interesting CM6632A chip, which supports both HDA codecs and I²S/I²C converters. Number of channels - 8+2 (analog + digital) output and 2+2 input. There is support for 192 kHz frequency. The chip can be clocked from three generators at once, 12, 24.5 and 22.5 MHz, which is what the creators of the card used. The decision to throw pasta from one end of the board with the DAC to the other with connectors remains not very clear.

All processing in both cards is done exclusively on program level. The maximum data rate of 96 kHz isn't much of an issue since 192 kHz content is virtually non-existent. Hi-Res did not give anything to ordinary users and did not reach the masses, and aesthetes and Hi-End lovers are unlikely to be interested in sound cards for $100.

Auto switch to headphones

  • Creative: There is
  • Asus: There is

When plugged into the headphone jack, the speakers are turned off. This feature was first implemented in integrated audio as part of the AC'97 and HDA standard. First, the detection of connected headphones was carried out by impedance, and then by a mechanical sensor. External cards with good converters are not inferior to integrated sound in this regard. However, in practice this can cause problems.

Bundled software

  • Creative: there is a set of software on the disk, a driver update on the manufacturer’s website
  • Asus: the same installation kit on CD and on the manufacturer’s website

The software disc is the same as all other Creative products.

The appearance and contents of the Entertainment Console of the X-Fi card have already been described more than once in our materials. The Audio Control Panel comes included right away and allows you to control absolutely all settings without the back and forth of a graphical menu, with the exception of the equalizer. Creative Volume Panel - it's unclear why required program, supplied for assortment. An important difference between drivers for XP: they provide a choice of frequency and bit depth directly from the Entertainment Console. The frequency is limited to a choice of 48 or 96 kHz, regardless of the OS. This choice is typical for all Creative USB cards.



Panel Asus cards It's structured very strangely. Parameters can only be selected via context menu By right button mice!

There is an interesting option for setting the headphone output volume limit.

In the wilds Asus settings has a separate option - Dolby Home Theater v4, which seems to have surpassed the Creative cards in terms of the number of “improvers”.

44 kHz support

  • Creative: No
  • Asus: There is

The Creative card contains two crystal oscillators and also has 44 kHz support at the DSP level. However, drivers for neither Windows XP nor Windows 7/8 do not support operation in 44 kHz mode: in the device settings you can only set 48 kHz or 96 kHz. In a card for audiophiles, this indicates either inadequacy or complete incompetence of the developers. To listen to music, 99.9% of cases use a frequency of 44 kHz. We are looking forward to comments from the map developers themselves.

The Asus card has support for all frequencies: 44, 48, 88, 96, 192 kHz.

Availability of ASIO driver

  • Creative: No
  • Asus: There is

The lack of an ASIO driver for Creative cards is beyond our understanding. Best option listening to the Creative card - WASAPI interface and software resampling in the player. Conversion from 44 kHz to 48 or 96 will always be forced by the Windows sound engine, or you need to select the conversion on the fly in the media player. For example, in the foobar 2000 player:

Sound from speakers

The audition was conducted on active monitors Adam S2.5A and Adam ARTist 5. For comparison, the very well-known sound cards E-MU 1616M (CS4398) and E-MU 0204 USB (AK4396) were used.

First surprise: all the cards play completely differently! In first place in terms of sound quality is the E-MU 1616M card, in second place is the E-MU 0204 USB, in third place is the Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi HD, and in fourth place is the Asus Xonar U7.

The sound of the Asus card is least similar to the E-MU 1616M (despite the installed identical DACs). The problem with distortion at Asus is to blame, since we know for sure that the 1616M card has an unrivaled analog output implementation. This includes a measured 120 dB signal/noise, a measured 0.0003% distortion, and a wonderful clear sound experience. The 1616M is not much inferior in sound to the best implementations of rack-mounted studio devices, comparable to Pro Tools HD and Lynx Aurora, so we confidently choose the 1616M sound as a reference for devices in the category under $150. E-MU 0204 USB is inferior quite a bit. X-Fi HD sounds brighter and more accentuated on the high frequencies, therefore, despite all its effectiveness, it is a little further from the original sound. The Xonar U7 really disappointed us with its poor highs and rather sluggish sound. Perhaps this problem can be solved by flashing the firmware or drivers; We will definitely clarify this issue with the manufacturer. In any case, there should not be 0.01% distortion. Both the digital and analog parts of the card are capable of more.

Let's also criticize Creative for the lack of a 44 kHz mode. This is simply inexplicable, nonsense! How can you make an audiophile card, install two crystal oscillators and prohibit it from operating at 44 kHz? Don't provide the user with an ASIO driver that bypasses Windows? This is simply the wildest incompetence of the developers. The E-MU 0204 USB - a device for the same money - has no trace of such problems! There is a feeling that one division of the Creative company is mercilessly competing with another: persistently developing a bicycle with square wheels, when in the next room a racing sports car has long been developed and tested.

Sound in headphones

We used high resistance Sennheiser headphones HD600 (300 Ohm) and Beyerdynamic DT990 Pro (250 Ohm).

The volume is sufficient in both cases, but the Asus card has practically no headroom. Creative was able to surprise us once again. In terms of sound quality, the places were distributed as follows: in first place is E-MU 1616M, in second place is Sound Blaster X-Fi HD, in third place is E-MU 0204 USB, and in fourth place is Asus Xonar U7. The professional interface E-MU 0204 USB, in principle, performed well, but X-Fi HD looked like a clear favorite against its background and had a significantly larger volume headroom. The Asus Xonar U7 card is the quietest, but its volume increases sharply when processing is turned on. Perhaps this was done intentionally so that there was a so-called headroom for Dolby technologies and other auto-equalizers. Thus, the Asus card is the least suitable for simply listening to music; its emphasis is placed precisely on the effectiveness of processing. The squeals and hoots of the card fans remain completely incomprehensible to us.

Measurements in RMAA




Tests at the RMAA gave an "Excellent" rating. This means that the devices have no obvious flaws. It doesn't mean anything anymore. (But as soon as artificial intelligence will make human measurement analysis unnecessary, we will be the first to let you know!)

Both cards were tested through their own path, as they have the same high-quality CS5361 ADC.

A bit noisy better than Asus, for distortion - Creative. We were concerned about the appearance of the Asus graph in the floating tone intermodulation test: usually anomalies in this test indicate frequency conversion or some other digital processing. We rechecked all the settings several times. The results do not change. We carried out additional tests on Windows XP and Windows 7 that were completely installed. We used the most latest drivers And latest firmware. There is only one result: the Asus card has about 10 times more distortion at high frequencies.

Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook is the only sound card with an ExpressCard interface. Let's see how good it is compared to integrated sound.

It's no secret that integrated sound cards are usually no different outstanding quality. Unfortunately, this is true not only for desktop computers, but also for laptops. In particular, in my personal laptop Fujitsu Siemens ESPRIMO M9400 the headphone output is very noisy. In low-impedance and sensitive headphones (for example, such as the Creative EP630 and Philips SHE9500 we have already reviewed), noise caused by work can be easily heard hard drive and graphics adapter.

At the same time, I quite often use my laptop to listen to music through headphones, and this situation naturally did not suit me. Unlike desktops, where you can install any sound card from dozens existing models, laptops have limited expansion options. Therefore, when choosing a sound card for use with a laptop computer, you have to focus primarily on external solutions with a USB interface. However, they are usually quite large, and many also require external power, which makes it impossible to carry them with you all the time.

Some professional audio manufacturers - such as Echo or EMU - make PCMCIA sound cards, but my laptop (like most modern laptops) only has an ExpressCard slot. This is precisely the reason for purchasing the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook sound card, which is the only sound card in the world designed for installation in the ExpressCard slot. So, meet the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook.

Delivery set, appearance, interfaces

The card comes in a small box with a traditional Creative design.

In addition to the sound card itself, the box contains a traditional set of waste paper in five languages, a terrible quality wired headset, a driver and a very nice carrying case.

The Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook is almost completely hidden in the ExpessCard slot; only the “head” remains outside, on which there are three connectors: output, input and a connector for connecting the so-called Speaker Docking Module. This very module is necessary for analog connection of a sound card to 7.1 or 5.1 format acoustics. It is not included in the package, and the possibility of purchasing it in the CIS countries is questionable.

The card's stereo output is combined with a digital optical output, and the input (to which you can connect both a microphone and linear sources) is combined with a digital optical input. Thus, the owner of a laptop X-Fi receives a complete set of digital audio interfaces. In my opinion, when watching movies on multi-channel soundtrack In Dolby Digital and DTS formats, it makes sense to output sound to an external receiver via an optical output. The Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook copes with this task brilliantly.

Functions

Despite the name, the X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook does not include the Creative X-Fi chip (EMU20K1). First of all, this means that the card is poorly suited for recreating a three-dimensional sound environment in computer games, but this does not matter for a laptop, since mobile computers(even the most powerful ones) are not intended for games. Much more important is that X-Fi Xtreme Audio has higher quality digital-to-analog converters (DACs) than the built-in sound card. Creative doesn't mention the components used anywhere, but as far as I was able to understand while scouring the Internet, the XFXA uses a CS4382A DAC manufactured by the highly respected company Crystal Semiconductor and a WM8775 ADC manufactured by Wolfson Microelectronics. If the DAC level is quite comparable to household Hi-Fi equipment, then the ADC is much inferior to it in quality (this theory will subsequently be confirmed by measurements). The sound card supports two proprietary Creative technologies - CMSS-3D and X-Fi Crystalizer. The first of them makes the sound in headphones pseudo-three-dimensional and is absolutely useless in real life. The second technology is supposed to significantly improve the quality of compressed audio (such as MP3), we will discuss it a little later.

Drivers and software

The sound card was tested on a Fujitsu Siemens ESPRIMO M9400 laptop (Core 2 Duo T5250 processor, 3 GB random access memory, Intel chipset GM965) running the Windows Vista Ultimate operating system. I would like to point out right away that the drivers supplied on the included disk are simply terrible. Firstly, they are very outdated, and secondly, their installation procedure takes no less than 1 hour and 15 minutes. I recommend not even unpacking this disk, but downloading it immediately new version drivers from the Creative website. The only caveat is that the version of PowerDVD recorded on the included disc cannot be installed separately. If you need it, you will have to first install all the bundled software, and then update the driver to the latest version. In general, Creative is not very willing to write drivers for its devices; new versions are usually released every six months or less.

Addition from 01/16/2009: after Windows installations Vista SP1 the sound card began to experience problems - for example, periodic “stuck” sound. As of January 2009, Creative has not yet released a driver version that is fully compatible with Vista SP1. In addition to the drivers themselves, you will need the Creative Console Launcher utility, since some sound card settings (for example, the analog input operating mode) can only be changed with its help. Unlike other X-Fi sound cards, the Xtreme Audio Notebook is limited to Entertainment Mode only. There are no Game Mode or Audio Creation Mode. The card does not support the ASIO interface and therefore cannot be used for professional work with sound.

It is worth noting that X-Fi Xtreme Audio works well with the sound card integrated into the laptop, which allows you to perform various interesting tricks, for example, two people listening to different music on one laptop.

Measurements

It so happened that just while I was writing this material, I briefly came across the professional external audio interface EMU 0202. I took this opportunity to take some measurements of the analog path of the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook sound card using the well-known RightMark Audio Analyzer package.

Operating mode: 16 bit 44 kHz

Noise level, dB (A)
Dynamic range, dB (A)
THD, %
THD + Noise, dB (A)
IMD + Noise, %
Stereo crosstalk, dB
IMD at 10 kHz, %
General performance

Excellent

As you can see, the X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook shows excellent playback quality even in 16-bit 44 kHz mode, traditionally the most difficult for non-professional Creative sound cards. Let's check whether the sound card suffers from forced oversampling at 48 kHz:

Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook Line-Out

Operating mode: 16 bit 48 kHz

Frequency response (from 40 Hz to 15 kHz), dB
Noise level, dB (A)
Dynamic range, dB (A)
THD, %
THD + Noise, dB (A)
IMD + Noise, %
Stereo crosstalk, dB
IMD at 10 kHz, %
General performance

Excellent

Judging by the fact that the values ​​of intermodulation distortion have almost halved, forced oversampling is taking place. It is of quite high quality, but in any case, when listening to music from a computer, it is better to use the SSRC plugin for your favorite player. Now let's check the quality in external loop mode by connecting the linear X-Fi output Xtreme Audio Notebook to its line input (16 bit 48 kHz):

Frequency response (from 40 Hz to 15 kHz), dB
Noise level, dB (A)
Dynamic range, dB (A)
THD, %
THD + Noise, dB (A)
IMD + Noise, %
Stereo crosstalk, dB
IMD at 10 kHz, %
General performance

Very good

As I expected, the input of X-Fi Xtreme Audio is significantly inferior in quality to the output. And now the deadly number - measuring the quality of the Realtek HD Audio audio codec integrated into the laptop. Since I had the EMU 0202 at my disposal for literally 20 minutes, I had to test the integrated sound using a linear X-Fi input. Despite this, Realtek fully lived up to the expectations placed on it. :)

Realtek HD Audio Line-Out

Operating mode: 16 bit 48 kHz

Frequency response (from 40 Hz to 15 kHz), dB
Noise level, dB (A)
Dynamic range, dB (A)
THD, %
THD + Noise, dB (A)
IMD + Noise, %
Stereo crosstalk, dB
IMD at 10 kHz, %
General performance

The advantage of X-Fi over integrated sound is obvious. At the same time, I would like to note the undoubted progress of built-in audio cards: Realtek HD Audio is at least as good in quality as Creative SB Live sound cards! ten years ago.

Sound quality (subjective listening)

Having connected headphones to the audio output of the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook sound card, I was pleasantly surprised... by the silence. No hissing, no buzzing, no “sounds of space” or other annoying interference - excellent! Compared to an integrated sound card, X-Fi produces much clearer and more detailed sound. The timbres of instruments are transmitted more accurately. For example, when listening to Astor Piazzola's Five Tango Sensations performed by the Kronos Quartet (Nonesuch Records, recorded 1991), the string instruments began to sound more like themselves. The increased resolution also had a good effect on the sound of complex multi-layered rock compositions: on the album Yes - Close To The Edge, the instruments stopped falling into mush.

Overall, the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook sounds brighter and more detailed than the Philips CD604 desktop CD player (which uses two TDA1543A DACs in parallel). However, the Philips CD604 has a sound that is less dry, more exciting and emotional. It is worth noting the fact that when using Creative headphones X-Fi provides more high level volume than the integrated sound card.

The X-Fi Crystalizer function turned out to be unexpectedly useful. When it is turned on, the level of high and low frequencies rises, plus significant compression of the dynamic range occurs (the audio card artificially increases the volume quiet sounds). When listening to music, this only spoils the impression, but watching films with a quiet soundtrack becomes much less tiring: you don’t have to listen hard all the time to make out the words of the characters. The effect is especially noticeable when using computer plastic Cheburashka speakers.

Bottom line

The Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook sound card has a lot of objective disadvantages, including the lack of a cable for connecting to multi-channel speakers, weak driver support from the manufacturer, unsuitability for professional work with sound, low quality line input and a fairly high cost (450 hryvnia or 90 dollars). In my opinion, almost all of these shortcomings are crossed out by the fact that the X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook is the only sound card in the world with an ExpressCard interface. At the same time, its analog output really provides very good sound quality. If you want to achieve from your laptop high-quality sound, but you can’t carry an external USB audio interface with you everywhere, you simply have no other choice. Although, for my part, I have to say that if the headphone output on my laptop was less noisy, I would not even consider the Creative X-Fi Xtreme Audio Notebook as a purchase.

The Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi HD external sound card is designed to significantly improve sound quality thanks to a whole range of advantages. The device can be easily connected to a laptop or PC, and it is equipped with conveniently located connectors for a microphone and playback devices. It is worth immediately mentioning the sound amplification function and the ability to easily adjust the volume level of the outgoing audio stream. The rear panel of the sound card features an optical port, a gold-plated stereo RCA jack, and an integrated phono stage that allows you to directly record the sound played from your vinyl record.

The device fully supports special Media Toolbox 6 software, which has a convenient intuitive interface and allows you to easily record digital audio, as well as convert it to various audio formats. Thanks to SBX Pro Studio technology, you can play video or audio files with a “live sound” effect, for example when watching movies or listening to music.

Superior sound quality
One of the main advantages of this model is the sound USB cards Sound Blaster line is the ability to reproduce sound in superior quality. At the same time, the signal-to-noise ratio is 114 dB.

SBX Pro Studio technology
The Sound Blaster X-Fi HD model is equipped with SBX Pro Studio technology, which significantly improves sound quality both while gaming and when watching movies or listening to music.

A great choice for fans of vinyl records!
In addition to all the other benefits, the sound card is equipped with a phono stage with RIAA equalizer, which allows you to easily connect your vinyl record player to it and thus directly convert the sound to CD or MP3 formats.

Sound amplifier for your headset
The Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi HD also features a superb integrated audio amplifier that works great even with premium headphones, where impedance can reach 330 ohms.

Fast and easy connection
Among other advantages of the device, it is worth highlighting the presence of conveniently located audio jacks for headphones and a microphone with a gold-plated frame. In addition, the device is equipped with a separate volume control in the form of a special toggle switch located on the front panel of the sound card.

Fully compatible with Windows 8
The developers of the audio card did a great job not only on the hardware, but also on the software component of their brainchild. Thereby, sound drivers for Sound Blaster X-Fi HD allow the device to work perfectly even when paired with operating system Windows 8.

Technical indicators

Basic:
- Sound technology: X-Fi.
- Signal to noise ratio: 114 dB.
- Channel output: stereo.
- Audio technology used: SBX Pro Studio.
- Sound quality: 24 bit/96 kHz.
- Main connection port: USB 2.0.
- Warranty period: 1 year.

Connection:
- Optical TOSLINK output.
- Optical TOSLINK input.
- One 1/4" microphone input that fully complies with RIAA standards.
- Two line input RCA.
- Headphone output 1/4".
- Two RCA line outputs.

List of compatible OS:
Windows8, WindowsXP SP2 or higher, Windows Vista SP1 or higher, Windows7 and Windows10.

System requirements:
- Compatible OS: Microsoft Windows10, Windows8, Windows7, Windows Vista, Windows XP (Professional x64 Edition, Service Pack 2 or more).
- Intel processor Core2 Duo or AMD equivalent with recommended clock frequency 2.2 GHz or more.
- Availability of a free USB port.
- Minimum amount of RAM: 1 GB.
- Amount of free memory on the hard drive: 600 MB.
- Headphones or speakers with an amplifier.
- CD-ROM or DVD-ROM drive for software installation.
- Availability of Internet connection.

Equipment:
- Sound Blaster X-Fi HD sound card.
- Guide for quick connection and software installation.
- Instructions for the user.
- Adapter with RCA connectors and audio input jack.
- USB cable 1.5 m long.
- Installation CD.
- CD with Media Toolbox 6 application.


Top